|Year : 2018 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 71
Relation between socioeconomic indicators and children dental caries in Iran: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Mohammadreza Amiresmaili1, Saeed Amini2, Arash Shahravan3, Reza Goudarzi4, Seyed Hossein Saberi Anari4, Zohre Anbari5, Mahtab Ghanbarnejad6
1 Department of Health Management, Policy and Economics, Faculty of Management and Medical Informatics, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
2 Health Services Management Research Center, Institute for Futures Studies in Health, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
3 Endodontology Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
4 Modeling in Health Research Center, Institute for Futures Studies in Health, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
5 Educational Development Center, Arak University of Medical Sciences, Arak, Iran
6 Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Institute for Futures Studies in Health, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
|Date of Submission||30-Sep-2017|
|Date of Acceptance||30-Oct-2017|
|Date of Web Publication||14-Aug-2018|
Department of Health Services Management, Faculty of Management and Medical Informatics, Campus of Kerman University of Medical Sciences, 7 Bagh Sq., Kerman
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
The relationship between households' socioeconomic situation (SES) and children dental caries has been assessed in many Iranian studies to evaluate the effect of public dental care programs supporting the poor. Hence, this study through systematic review and meta-analysis has presented a conclusion in this regard. Domestic and foreign databases were searched using keywords designed by concept map. Time limit to search the databases included articles published from 1994 to 2017. Twenty-five articles were entered to the final step of the study, in which 49 relationships between SES and dental caries were assessed. Heterogeneity between studies was assessed using I2. Publication bias has been assessed using funnel plot and Egger's test. The data were assessed by STATA 13.1. Odds ratio and mean difference of children dental caries in high SES households in comparison with low SES households were 0.41 (confidence interval [CI]: 0.30, 0.52) and −0.49 (CI: −0.85, −0.13), respectively. The CI in both cases did not include “null or no effect line,” so there was a significant inverse relation between SES and dental caries. Despite the emphasis on upstream documents on equity in access to dental health services, there was high difference between SES groups in this regard. It is necessary to revise dental health programs at the country level to decrease these differences.
Keywords: Dental caries, Iran, meta-analysis, socioeconomic factors
|How to cite this article:|
Amiresmaili M, Amini S, Shahravan A, Goudarzi R, Saberi Anari SH, Anbari Z, Ghanbarnejad M. Relation between socioeconomic indicators and children dental caries in Iran: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Prev Med 2018;9:71
|How to cite this URL:|
Amiresmaili M, Amini S, Shahravan A, Goudarzi R, Saberi Anari SH, Anbari Z, Ghanbarnejad M. Relation between socioeconomic indicators and children dental caries in Iran: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Prev Med [serial online] 2018 [cited 2021 Jul 23];9:71. Available from: https://www.ijpvmjournal.net/text.asp?2018/9/1/71/239005
| Introduction|| |
Dental caries is one of the most prevalent childhood diseases, especially in the developing countries. Untreated dental caries lead to problems in eating and sleeping, pain, need to invasive restoration treatment, emergency dentistry visit, hospitalization, low quality of life (QoL), systemic health problems and in rare cases leads to death,, however treatment for dental diseases is costly especially for poor and low income families. Dental caries prevalence has had a decreasing trend in the past decades both in developing and developed countries, but it has a high prevalence in low socioeconomic families of all these countries.,
Many studies have been performed in different cities of Iran about the relation between the households' socioeconomic situation (SES) and children dental caries [Table 1]. However, it is not specified to what extent different socioeconomic parameters such as education level, income, and job have a significant relationship with generating caries lesions or caries experience. In other words, the situation of this relation is not specified for Iran, totally. Hence, it is necessary to study first the existence and second the severity of this relation.
|Table 1: Concept map and designed keywords for search in different databases|
Click here to view
This is while a great importance has been paid to the health care and equity in access between the poor and the rich by upstream documents, including Iran's 20-Year Development Vision (2005–2025) and also Articles 3, 29, and 43 of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran., In a national program, dental health services have been integrated into the Iran healthcare network in 1994 to improve the access of deprived people to the dental services. The latest national program to support the poor was Health Sector Evolution Plan (HSEP) by the 11th Iran government in 2014. Among the most important goals of the HSEP are providing health insurance for all Iranians, improving suburban regions access to health services, and increasing people health literacy. Therefore, public health care has been emphasized in upstream documents. By attention to high importance given by the upstream documents to the healthcare, this systematic review and meta-analysis study has been designed to assess the children caries situation in terms of their households' SES.
The aim of this study is to assess the probable relationship between SES of Kerman city households and their children dental caries. Such a study can fill the gaps and weaknesses in present knowledge and methods, and also, it can be possible to assess the impact of confounders such as the study type, its quality, and the size and age of the population on the relationship severity.
| Methods|| |
All of epidemiological studies including cross-sectional, case–control, cohort, and clinical trials in all age and sex groups were eligible to enter the study. The specified question of this study was: Is there a significant relationship between caries and households' SES? The purpose of SES is each type of relationship with education in school or university, type of job, and income level.
The Global Burden of Diseases Study in 2010 has defined dental caries as “teeth with unmistakable coronal cavity at dentine level, root cavity in cementum that feels soft or leathery to probing, temporary or permanent restorations with a caries lesion.”
Search strategy to obtain related studies
The Iranian databases of Scientific Information Database (http://sid.ir/), Barakat Knowledge Network System (http://www.barakatkns.com), and foreign databases of Scopus (www.scopus.com), Web of Science (http://www.isiknowledge.com), Google Scholar (https://scholar.google.nl/), PubMed (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed), and EMBASE (https://www.embase.com) were searched systematically. There was no limitation about the searched languages in databases. Dental care services were integrated into Iran healthcare networks in 1994 to dental health services could be accessible for all. Hence, the history of Iran dental services could be divided into before the integration and after it. Therefore, time period for search in databases considered from 1994 to 2016.
After breaking the project topic into keywords which indicate the main concepts of the study, using brainstorm, the alternative keywords that any authors may have used in their articles were determined. Accordingly, the concept map and keywords for search in different database are shown in [Table 1]. As explained in the findings, only observational studies entered into the current study, so it is not possible to define all of PICOT components (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, Time duration) to search in scientific databases.
The process of building a search query for each column was determined, and after completing each column, they were combined with each other to generate the final search query. As an example, the final search query for PubMed database is as below:
(((((((((((((((((caries) OR periodontics) OR gingivitis) OR dentition) OR Deciduous) OR orodental) OR dental) OR “Oral”) OR decayed) OR decay) OR dmf) OR carious) OR dmft) OR dmfs)) AND (((((((((((((((((((((((access) OR pocket) OR pockets) OR poverty) OR risk factor) OR quality of life) OR utilization) OR accessing) OR accessib*) OR accessab*) OR inequal*) OR inequit*) OR financial) OR finance) OR University) OR School) OR economical) OR economic) OR social) OR socioeconomic*) OR occupation*) OR income) OR education*))) AND Iran.
Other databases were searched on the basis of their search guidance, too. Moreover searching electronic databases, reference lists of retrieved articles, related books, organizations and government guidelines, and websites were searched. Furthermore, we communicated with authors of published and unpublished articles, theses, conference reports, and so on to obtain more information about their projects.
First and second authors independently performed full work of searching the mentioned databases, including search and extract articles, assessment validity, and duplications. Characteristics of the final retrieved articles were entered into EndNote X8, Thompson Reuters.
After reading title and abstract, unrelated articles excluded from the study cycle. The excluded studies were archived along with the reason of rejecting. Calibration exercise was 10% so that to determine inter-examiner agreement, authors 4, 5, and 6 read 10% of the articles (κ = 0.85).
The criteria for including were studies in 6–65 years old, reporting risk factors for dental caries, especially socioeconomic factors (although socioeconomic factors were not their main goals), studies conducted in national or provincial or city levels of Iran published in local and international prestigious journals, studies with random samples, response rate more than 50%, and attrition rate lower than 50%. The criteria for excluding studies were letter to editor, editorials, grey literature, case studies, studies before 1995 (because new era in Iran dental health started in 1995), studies about caries in persons with other diseases such as cancer, diabetes, studies in special groups such as pregnant women and studies about water fluoride, educational programs, diagnostic and laboratory studies, and dental services consent.
The main characteristics of the included studies were extracted using the second and third authors. For this, a pilot-tested spreadsheet was developed and the studies information including authors, year of publication, study design, place of study, location of data collection, study population, subjects' years of old, dependent variable, SEP parameter, low SEP, high SEP, effect measure, effect estimate, and Newcastle Ottawa scale (NOS) was extracted.
Articles with primary requirements which were included in data extraction were further assessed for quality using Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale (NOS). Authors number 1 and 5 assessed the quality of studies using this scale. In this scale, (1) selection of the study population has 0–4 items, (2) comparability of subjects has 0–2 items, and finally, (3) outcome for cohort and cross-sectional studies has 0–3 items. Each study receives 1 point per each item. For part 1, the items include representativeness of the exposed cohort, selection of the unexposed cohort, ascertainment of exposure, and demonstration that the outcome of interest was not present at the start of the study. For part 2, the items include comparability for core factors and comparability for additional factors, and for part 3, the items include assessment of outcome, sufficient duration of follow-up for the outcome to occur, and adequacy of follow-up of cohorts.
The maximum number each study can obtain from NOS is 9 (4 + 2 + 3). If a study obtains score 7 or above, it has high quality. Studies with scores between 5 and 7 have moderate quality and studies with score lower than 5 have low quality.
To make possible the comparison between the studies, the highest and the lowest SES extracted from each study, the lowest SES was considered as the reference. Risk estimate was extracted from each study, and if one study has not reported risk estimate, we extracted it using raw data in that study.
The significant relationship between SES and dental caries both in odds ratio (OR) studies and mean difference (MD) studies was interpreted based on their situation from vertical line (or no effect line or null line) in forest plots. This line means that there is no relation between independent and dependent variables. Relative statistics such as OR has a null effect value equal to 1 and absolute statistics such as MD has a null effect value equal to 0. If the confidence interval (CI) of each study touch the vertical line (1 for OR and 0 for MD), the result is not statistically significant.,
The studies heterogeneity assessed using I2 index. Because of expecting heterogeneity both between and within studies, random-effects model was used.
The publication bias assessed using funnel plot and Egger's test. Funnel plots are used when there are more than 10 studies. If there is no publication bias, the funnel plot turns upside down or become inverted. The considered index locates on the horizontal axis and its standard error (SE) on the vertical axis. The larger the size of the study, the greater its precision and its effect measure locates higher in the funnel plot and vice versa for smaller studies. In addition, the estimates of smaller studies are away from each other in the bottom of the graph and the estimates of larger studies are close to each other at the top of the graph, so the graph inverts to a funnel-shaped plot.
Statistical power of the Egger's test in indicating publication bias is higher than Begg's test. Hence, to interpret the funnel plot statistically, we used Egger's test. If there is no publication bias in meta-analysis, its Egger's test should become insignificant statistically and its CI should include zero number. The data analyzed using Stata software, Stata 13.1 (Stata Corp, College Station, TX, USA).
| Results|| |
By attention to the required different methods of search in scientific databases, the procedure of article selection in these databases is described here.
After searching search strategy in PubMed with filters of the year (from 1995 up to now), study on human beings, and search in title/abstract, 244 articles were retrieved. After removing unrelated studies such as studies on diabetic, asthma, dialysis and hepatitis patients, also knowledge and attitude studies, and after studying the articles full text, 16 articles were identified and were entered into the EndNote software.
Web of Science
After defining search strategy and period, 454 articles were retrieved. Then, after the articles were refined on the basis of categories, document type, and search in the researchers' desired fields, 205 articles were obtained. In the next step, by studying the abstract and full text of articles, 14 studies were obtained finally and were entered into the EndNote software.
After writing search strategy in EMBASE database, 493 articles were retrieved. The articles were decreased to 74 by implementing filters on study year and type and by studying the titles, abstracts, and full texts, nine articles were remained finally and were entered into the EndNote software.
The first searches in Scopus in documents part and by putting “or” and “and” between the keywords and applying limitations on date range and document type yielded 994 articles. After studying the title of the article, those in other subject areas were removed. At the final step by studying the abstract and full texts, 14 articles were remained and were entered into the EndNote software.
Barakat Knowledge Network System
The search process in this scientific database led to 32 articles, and after reading the titles, 16 articles remained, and finally, by reading the abstracts/full texts, 12 articles were remained and were entered into the EndNote software.
Scientific Information Database
The search process in this scientific database led to 118 articles, which after removing unrelated articles, 15 cases entered into the EndNote software.
So, the final articles entered to the EndNote were 80 articles (16 for PubMed, 14 for Web of Science, 9 for EMBASE, 14 for Scopus, 12 for BKNS, and 15 for SID). After deleting the duplicate articles, 25 articles remained finally.
After the above final retrieved articles were entered into the EndNote software and by removing the duplicate articles, 25 articles (in which 49 relationships between SES and dental caries were assessed) were entered to the final step of the systematic review and meta-analysis. The total number of the participants in these studies was 78,434 persons. The studies quality assessment using NOS indicated that their NOS located between 3 and 6, so the studies had low to moderate quality.
These 25 articles had assessed the relationship between SES and dental caries in two ways. The first groups had mentioned A (healthy exposed), B (patient exposed), C (unhealthy exposed), and D (patient unexposed) cases in their studies, which we could extract OR from them using the order of “case–control OR calculator” in Stata software. The second groups had mentioned mean dental caries and its 95% CI along with SES of the households, in which MD was derived by decreasing mean dental caries in households with high SES than households with low SES using the order of “effect size based on mean comparison” in Stata software. By attention that all retrieved studies were cross-sectional, so the type of study has not been stated in [Table 2].
|Table 2: Characteristics of cross-sectional studies included in the systematic review and meta-analysis|
Click here to view
Subgroup and overall summary of the relationship between socioeconomic situation and dental caries
The relationship between household socioeconomic situation and dental caries in the studies when odds ratio was extractable
[Figure 1] indicates that the OR of the relationship between households' income and children dental caries is 0.12 (CI: −0.14, 0.38). This CI does not include no effect line (or null line), so there is an inverse significant relationship between household income and dental caries. In other word, dental caries decreases 0.88 by increasing household income.
|Figure 1: Forest plot of the relationship between household socioeconomic situation and children dental caries based on odds ratio index (with 95% confidence interval in terms of author name and research year)|
Click here to view
The OR of relationship between mother education and children dental caries is 0.14 (CI: 0.07, 0.21) which does not include no effect line, so dental caries decreases 0.84 by increasing mother education which is significant statistically.
The OR of the relationship between mother job situation and children dental caries is 0.60 (CI: 0.40, 0.80). This CI does not include no effect line, so it is significant statistically so that employed mothers with a probability of 0.40 have children with lower caries rate than others.
The OR of the relationship between father education situation and children dental caries is 0.55 (CI: 0.24, 0.86). This CI does not include no effect line, so it is significant statistically so that employed fathers with a probability of 0.45 have children with lower caries rate than others.
The OR of the relationship between SES and children dental caries is 0.63 (0.36, 0.90). This CI does not include no effect line, so it is significant statistically so that the OR of dental caries in children belonging to higher SES households' is 0.37 lower than other households.
Finally, the OR of the relationship between father job situation and children dental caries is 0.25 (CI: −0.04, 0.54). This CI does not include no effect line, so it is significant statistically, and the probability of dental caries in children with employed fathers is 0.75 lower than other children.
Overall, the OR of the relationship between all SES indices and children dental caries is 0.41 (CI: 0.30, 0.52). This CI does not include no effect line so that the OR of children dental caries in higher SES households is 0.59 lower than the children belonging to low SES households.
The relationship between household socioeconomic situation and dental caries in the studies when mean difference was extractable
[Figure 2] indicates that the amount of MD between father education and children dental caries is-0.82 (−1.77, 0.13). This CI has included no effect line to a small amount. Hence, although only one study among five has rejected this relation and others are inverse significant statistically, this relationship is not significant.
|Figure 2: Forest plot of the relationship between household socioeconomic situation and children dental caries based on mean difference index (with 95% confidence interval in terms of author name and research year)|
Click here to view
The MD of the relationship between mother education and children dental caries was −0.49 (CI: −0.86, −0.12). This CI has not included no effect line so that by increasing mother education, dental caries decreases significantly.
The MD of the relationship between household income and children dental caries is 0.25 (CI: −1.02, 1.51). This CI has not included effect line, so there is no significant relationship between household income and dental caries.
The MD of the relationship between household SES and children dental caries is −0.45 (CI: −0.90, 0.01). This CI has included no effect line in a small amount. Hence, although the most of studies in this subgroup approve this relationship, the final analysis does not approve such a relationship.
The MD of the relationship between parents' education and children dental caries is −0.31 (CI: −0.47, 0.14). This CI has not included no effect line so that by increasing parents' education, children dental caries decreases significantly.
The MD of the relationship between father employment and children dental caries is −1.62 (CI: −2.63, −1.11). This CI does not include no effect line, so this relation is significant statistically. In other words, dental caries in children with employed fathers is lower than others, significantly.
Overall, the MD of the relationship between all SES indices and children dental caries is −0.49 (CI: −0.85, −0.13). This CI does not include no effect line so that by improving household SES, children dental caries decreases, significantly.
Funnel plot of the relationship between household SES and dental caries in studies which OR was extractable is indicated in [Figure 3]. The standard error is plotted against OR. An asymmetric funnel plot indicates low level of publication or small-study bias, further supporting the reliability of the overall findings. Further, publication bias was not approved using Egger's test, because first its test is not statistically significant (P>\t\=0.374) and second its CI includes zero (−1.96, 5.01).
|Figure 3: Funnel plot indicating publication bias for odds ratio studies|
Click here to view
Funnel plot of the relationship between household SES and dental caries in studies which MD was extractable is indicated in [Figure 3]. The standard error is plotted against MD. An asymmetric funnel plot indicates low level of publication or small-study bias, further supporting the reliability of the overall findings. Further, publication bias was not approved using Egger's test, because first its test is not statistically significant (P>\t\=0.254) and second its CI includes zero (−2.91, 10.48) [Figure 4].
|Figure 4: Funnel plot indicating publication bias for mean difference studies|
Click here to view
Heterogeneity rate in the studies that had assessed the OR and MD of the relationship between SES and children dental caries was 91.9 and 98.4, respectively [Table 1] and [Table 2]. I2 index lower than 25%, between 25% and 75%, and higher than 75% considered as low, medium, and high heterogeneity respectively, so the heterogeneity rate in this study was high. Therefore, random effect model used to analyze the articles.
| Discussion|| |
Systematic review and meta-analysis of the relationship between household SES and children dental caries were studied in this study. As results indicated, OR of children dental caries in high SES households in comparison with low SES households is 41% (CI: 0.30, 0.52). Because this CI does not include null or no effect line (1 line) and also the OR is lower than 1, so there is an inverse significant relationship between SES and children dental caries. Further, the results indicated that MD of children dental caries in high SES households in comparison with low SES households is −0.49 (CI: −0.85, −0.13). Because this CI does not include null or no effect line (zero line) and also the MD is lower than 0, so there is an inverse significant relationship between SES and children dental caries.
The articles used in this study were different in terms of study design and methods used to assess dental caries and SES and had high level of heterogeneity. For example, the authors of these articles have used different indices such as DMFT, DMFS, caries, and caries free. In addition, the effect of confounders of the relationship between SES factors and dental caries has not been controlled. However, most of the articles have approved the significant inverse relationship between these indicators. Further, the number of studies was favorable so that 25 articles were entered to the final step of the study, which totally have assessed 50 relationships between the indicators.
The inverse relationship between parents' education level and children dental caries was significant in this study. Studies in other countries support this finding. The children with higher mother education level had lower dental caries. Further, there was a significant inverse relationship between father education level and dental caries in Greece and Libya.,
The households who have higher education levels usually have higher income level and better access to the dental services, also use preventive dental services more than others, and prevent harmful foods. In addition, parents with high level of education are probably more interested and responsible for health issues such as maintaining good diets and hygiene, so their children have more healthier teeth.
Overall, different studies have confirmed that the children with low-level education parents and low family incomes have more dental caries., In this study, there was a negative significant relationship between household income and dental caries in OR articles, but this relation was not significant in MD articles. In other words, among seven articles that had assessed the relation between income and dental caries, only two articles , have reported that there is a direct and significant relationship between income and dental caries which is in contradiction with studies abroad. The logic of these articles is that first high-income families can buy more sweets and snacks than others which is a contributory factor in creating dental caries  and second different income levels may not have a significant effect on dental health behaviors; moreover, some families may not express their real monthly income. However, as mentioned, there was a negative significant relationship between household income and dental caries in other studies. One of the reasons is that low-income families consume foods that are low in nutrients and high in sugar and fat, so their children are more susceptible for dental caries. Furthermore, low-income families less visit a dentist and do less preventive and curative measures.
There was an inverse significant relationship between parents' employment situation and their children dental caries. A study in India indicated that children with unskilled mothers or housewives have dental caries twice more than children with skilled or employed mothers. Moreover, a study on Belgium children indicated that dental caries decreased as mothers' occupational level increased. However, studies in Japan, Brazil, and Mongolia indicated that there was no significant relationship between mother employment status and children dental caries.,, Positive and significant relationship between mother employment status and dental caries may be because of increasing household income when mother is employed and therefore higher access to dental services. On the other hand, no significant relation between mother employment status and children dental caries in other mentioned studies may be because of development of dental health system which provides the needed services for all of population regardless of mother employment status, household income, or other variables.
Overall, there was an inverse significant relationship between households' SES and children dental caries in the current study. A systematic review on 272 articles indicated that children belonging to low SES families have higher dental caries prevalence in comparison with low SES families. Hence, the negative relation between SES and dental caries in countries with undeveloped and noncomprehensive dental health system, which people do not have access to the services irrespective of their SES, is a proven fact.
The services delivered by public sector do not include lower socioeconomic groups thoroughly or do not have required effectiveness. A study in Iran indicated that dental care costs have been an important factor in creating catastrophic costs in Iranian families. Further, low-income families because of low utilization of dental care services have been less exposed to the catastrophic costs. Public preventive dental programs such as water fluoridation are one of the best ways to reduce current inequalities. In addition, Iran ministry of health should avoid excessive concentration on costly and specialized dental services and consider people as patients, not customers.
In this regard, the governments and insurances have the main role. Currently, the situation of dental services coverage is not equitable and the poor should pay a large proportion of their low income on dental services. On the basis of Iran Dental Association, total dental costs have been 97 million US$ in 2011, in which only 11% has been financed by insurance system and the share of out of pocket costs has been 89%. Hence, dental insurance coverage has not been provided for considerable part of the population. By attention that the costs of dental complemental insurance are paid by employers or nongovernmental public sector, so the share of government contribution to dental costs is practically nothing.
Dental services have been included in the package of Iran health insurances, but only examination, radiography, extraction, molar surgery, dental health education, scaling and filling for 6–12 years old children are covered. Two main Iran insurance funds (i.e., social security and health insurance) covering more than 28% of the population allocate only 1% of their annual expenditures which indicate a low insurance support of the services.
Different studies in Iran have proposed strategies to deal with inequality in utilization of dental services. The common items include designing and development of basic and complementary health insurance programs to cover dental costs and allocate more public resources to the dental services and performing preventive and educational programs.,,,
The articles used in this systematic review and meta-analysis had different qualities. Some studies have been performed in small cities and others in large cities, so studies were performed in local not in national level. Furthermore, the households with the best SES were compared with the worst SES in terms of childhood dental caries. This cannot indicate the real status of inequality in access to the dental services.
This study confirms inverse relationship between SES and dental caries. Hence, we can conclude that public and governmental supports, insurance coverage, and Iran health network have not been able to improve utilization of dental services by low socio-economic groups. Therefore, it seems necessary to revise dental health services in favor of the poor.
Financial support and sponsorship
This paper is retrieved from a doctoral thesis. The Deputy Research of Kerman University of Medical Sciences has supported the funding (Grant Number: 95000277).
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
van Wyk C, van Wyk PJ. Trends in dental caries prevalence, severity and unmet treatment need levels in South Africa between 1983 and 2002. SADJ 2010;65:310, 312-4.
Lee HH, Lewis CW, Saltzman B, Starks H. Visiting the emergency department for dental problems: Trends in utilization, 2001 to 2008. Am J Public Health 2012;102:e77-83.
Chi DL, Masterson EE. A serial cross-sectional study of pediatric inpatient hospitalizations for non-traumatic dental conditions. J Dent Res 2013;92:682-8.
Petersen PE. The World Oral Health Report 2003: Continuous improvement of oral health in the 21st
century – The approach of the WHO Global Oral Health Programme. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2003;31 Suppl 1:3-23.
Marthaler TM. Changes in dental caries 1953-2003. Caries Res 2004;38:173-81.
Petersen PE. Sociobehavioural risk factors in dental caries – International perspectives. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2005;33:274-9.
Moradi-Lakeh M, Vosoogh-Moghaddam A. Health sector evolution plan in Iran; equity and sustainability concerns. Int J Health Policy Manag 2015;4:637-40.
Marcenes W, Kassebaum NJ, Bernabé E, Flaxman A, Naghavi M, Lopez A, et al.
Global burden of oral conditions in 1990-2010: A systematic analysis. J Dent Res 2013;92:592-7.
Health Vice Chancellor. Oral Health Bureau, Integrating Oral Health to Primary Health Care System. Ministry of Health and Medical Education; 1994. p. 6-10.
Wells GA, Shea B, O'Connell D, Peterson J, Welch V, Losos V, et al
. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for Assessing the Quality of Nonrandomized Studies in Meta-Analyses. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, University of Ottawa; 2001. Available from: http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.htm
. [Last accessed on 2017 Nov 23].
Doi SAR, Williams GM; SpringerLink. Methods of Clinical Epidemiology. Springer Series on Epidemiology and Public Health. New York, NY: Springer; 2013. Available from: http://www.springer.com/ us/book/9783642371301
. [Last accessed on 2017 Nov 23].
Egger M, Smith GD, Phillips AN. Meta-analysis: Principles and procedures. BMJ 1997;315:1533-7.
Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997;315:629-34.
Meamar N, Ghazizadeh A, Mahmoodi S. DMFT (decayed, missing and filled teeth) index and related factors in 12- year- old school children in Sanandaj. Sci J Kurdistan Univ Med Sci 2000;5:26-30.
Toomarian L, Souri S, Farhadi H. Epidemiological evaluation of DMFT index in 12 – Year – Old students of Qom city in 1383. J Dent Sch Shahid Beheshti Univ Med Sci 2005;23:467-74.
Abedini H, Gilasi H, Daoodi E, Eshghi T, Karbasi M, Haidaryan M, et al
. Prevalence and causes of decay in primary teeth of children aged 2-6 years in Kashan. J Ilam Univ Med Sci 2013;21:115-23.
Vejdani J, Mohtasham Amiri Z, Rezaie M. Prevalence of nursing caries and associating factors in 2-4 year olds children. J Guilan Univ Med Sci 2006;14:10-7.
Toutouni H, Nokhostin MR, Amaechi BT, Zafarmand AH. The prevalence of early childhood caries among 24 to 36 months old children of Iran: Using the novel ICDAS-II method. J Dent (Shiraz) 2015;16:362-70.
Eskandarizadeh A, Sajadi FS, Torabi M, Sharifi M, Amini Z, Sahebghalam B, et al
. Caries free prevalence among 6, 12 & 15-year old school children in Kerman during 2000-2005. J Health Dev 2015;4:42-51.
Faezi M, Farhadi S, NikKerdar H. Correlation between DMFT, diet and social factors in primary school children of Tehran-Iran in 2009-2010. J Mashhad Dent Sch 2012;36:141-8.
Hematyar M, Masnavi A. Prevalence and risk factors of dental decays in 3-7 years old children referred to pediatric clinics of Islamic Azad University. J Qazvin Univ Med Sci 2009;13:87-94.
Javadinejad S, Karami M, Azizi H. Caries prevalence in 12-year-old children of Isfahan city expressed by the significant caries index. J Isfahan Dent Sch 2007;2:13-7.
Mehrabkhani M, Ajami B, Khademi M, Arastoo S. Evaluating risk factors of dental caries in children under 6-years-old supported by Welfare Organization of Mashhad in 2012. J Mashhad Dent Sch 2014;38:257-66.
Seyed Akhavan P, Azim Zade N, Asadi Nejad A. Study the situation of dental care, dental needs, DMFT and related factors in 12 years old students of Karaj province. J Res Dent Sci 2004;5:26-34.
Jahani Y, Eshraghian MR, Foroushani AR, Nourijelyani K, Mohammad K, Shahravan A, et al
. Effect of socio-demographic status on dental caries in pupils by using a multilevel hurdle model. Health 2013;5:1110.
Rezaei-Soufi L, Kasraei S, Jazaeri M, Khamverdi Z. Dental caries experience in 13-19-year-old Iranian students expressed by DMFT and significant caries index. DJH dentistry. 2013;3:45-52.
Shamsi M, Hidarnia A, Niknami S, Khorsandi M. The status of dental caries and some acting factors in a sample of Iranian women with pregnancy. World J Med Sci 2013;9:190-7.
Sajadi FS, Mosharafian S, Torabi M, Hajmohamadi S. Evaluation of DMFT index and significant caries index in 12-year-old students in Sirjan, Kerman. J Isfahan Dent Sch 2014;10:290-8.
Saied-Moallemi Z, Virtanen JI, Tehranchi A, Murtomaa H. Disparities in oral health of children in Tehran, Iran. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent 2006;7:262-4.
Rigi Ladez M, Ghanbariha M, Badiee M, Abdolazimi Z. The relationship between dental caries and some socio-economic factors in 35-44 years old adults in some urban areas of Sistan & Baluchestan. J Shahid Sadoughi Univ Med Sci 2012;20:454-63.
Pakpour AH, Hidarnia A, Hajizadeh E, Kumar S, Harrison AP. The status of dental caries and related factors in a sample of Iranian adolescents. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal 2011;16:e822-7.
Momeni A, Mardi M, Pieper K. Caries prevalence and treatment needs of 12-year-old children in the islamic republic of Iran. Med Princ Pract 2006;15:24-8.
Nabipour AR, Azvar K, Zolala F, Ahmadinia H, Soltani Z. The prevalence of early dental caries and its contributing factors among 3-6-year-old children in Varamin/Iran. J Health Dev 2013;2:12.
Nematollahi H, Mehrabkhani M, Esmaily HO. Dental caries experience and its relationship to socio-economic factors in 2-6 year old Kindergarten children in Birjand – Iran in 2007. J Mashhad Dent Sch 2009;32:325-32.
Kazerouni K, Mohammadi N, Ansari GH, Kamali Z. The effects of socio-economic status on dental caries incidence in a group of primary school children, Tehran-2000. Shahid Beheshti Univ Dent J 2005;22:51-9.
Hessari H, Vehkalahti MM, Eghbal MJ, Murtomaa HT. Oral health among 35- to 44-year-old Iranians. Med Princ Pract 2007;16:280-5.
Hessari H, Vehkalahti MM, Eghbal MJ, Samadzadeh H, Murtomaa HT. Oral health and treatment needs among 18-year-old Iranians. Med Princ Pract 2008;17:302-7.
Basir L, Hashemi E, Khataminia M, Ansarifar S. Evaluation of correlation between DMFT index and social factors in 3-6 years old children of Ahvaz Kindergartens. Jundishapur Sci Med J 2014;Suppl:17-26.
Tanaka K, Miyake Y, Sasaki S, Hirota Y. Socioeconomic status and risk of dental caries in Japanese preschool children: The Osaka maternal and child health study. J Public Health Dent 2013;73:217-23.
Huew R, Waterhouse PJ, Moynihan PJ, Maguire A. Prevalence and severity of dental caries in Libyan schoolchildren. Int Dent J 2011;61:217-23.
Oulis CJ, Tsinidou K, Vadiakas G, Mamai-Homata E, Polychronopoulou A, Athanasouli T, et al.
Caries prevalence of 5, 12 and 15-year-old greek children: A national pathfinder survey. Community Dent Health 2012;29:29-32.
Drewnowski A, Specter SE. Poverty and obesity: The role of energy density and energy costs. Am J Clin Nutr 2004;79:6-16.
Piovesan C, Mendes FM, Ferreira FV, Guedes RS, Ardenghi TM. Socioeconomic inequalities in the distribution of dental caries in Brazilian preschool children. J Public Health Dent 2010;70:319-26.
Kumar S, Tadakamadla J, Kroon J, Johnson NW. Impact of parent-related factors on dental caries in the permanent dentition of 6-12-year-old children: A systematic review. J Dent 2016;46:1-1.
Schwendicke F, Dörfer CE, Schlattmann P, Foster Page L, Thomson WM, Paris S, et al.
Socioeconomic inequality and caries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent Res 2015;94:10-8.
Mobley C, Marshall TA, Milgrom P, Coldwell SE. The contribution of dietary factors to dental caries and disparities in caries. Acad Pediatr 2009;9:410-4.
Dyer TA, Brocklehurst P, Glenny AM, Davies L, Tickle M, Issac A, et al.
Dental auxiliaries for dental care traditionally provided by dentists. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014;CD010076.
Kumar S, Tadakamadla J, Duraiswamy P, Kulkarni S. Dental caries and its socio-behavioral predictors- an exploratory cross-sectional study. J Clin Pediatr Dent 2016;40:186-92.
Jigjid B, Ueno M, Shinada K, Kawaguchi Y. Early childhood caries and related risk factors in Mongolian children. Community Dent Health 2009;26:121-8.
Reisine ST, Psoter W. Socioeconomic status and selected behavioral determinants as risk factors for dental caries. J Dent Educ 2001;65:1009-16.
Kavosi Z, Rashidian A, Pourreza A, Majdzadeh R, Pourmalek F, Hosseinpour AR, et al.
Inequality in household catastrophic health care expenditure in a low-income society of Iran. Health Policy Plan 2012;27:613-23.
Masood M, Masood Y, Newton T. Impact of national income and inequality on sugar and caries relationship. Caries Res 2012;46:581-8.
Hoseinpour R, Safari H. A Review of Statistics and Information in Dentistry. 1st
ed. Tehran: Iranian Dental Association; 2013. p. 79-106.
Jadidfard MP, Yazdani S, Khoshnevisan MH. Social insurance for dental care in Iran: A developing scheme for a developing country. Oral Health Dent Manag 2012;11:189-98.
Jahromi NN, Jafari A, Kavosi Z, Shokrpour N, Sajjadnia Z, Ravangard R, et al.
Demand for dental services in Shiraz, Iran, 2013. Health Care Manag (Frederick) 2016;35:340-9.
Sistani MMN, Hataminia Z, Hajiahmadi M, Khodadadi E. Nine years' trend of dental caries and severe early childhood caries among 3-6-year-old children in Babol, Northern Iran. Electron Physician 2017;9:4683-8.
Homaie Rad E, Kavosi Z, Arefnezhad M. Economic inequalities in dental care utilizations in Iran: Evidence from an urban region. Med J Islam Repub Iran 2016;30:383.
Safiri S, Kelishadi R, Heshmat R, Rahimi A, Djalalinia S, Ghasemian A, et al.
Socioeconomic inequality in oral health behavior in Iranian children and adolescents by the oaxaca-blinder decomposition method: The CASPIAN- IV study. Int J Equity Health 2016;15:143.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]
[Table 1], [Table 2]
|This article has been cited by|
||Evaluation of Risk Factors in Caries Formation in Children
| ||Berna Kuter,Alp Abidin Atesci,Ilhan Uzel |
| ||Balkan Journal of Dental Medicine. 2020; 24(1): 45 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Did the extended coverage policy contribute to alleviating socioeconomic inequality in untreated dental caries of both children and adolescents in South Korea?
| ||Bo-Mi Shin,Se-Hwan Jung,Myoung-Hee Kim,Jae-In Ryu |
| ||BMC Oral Health. 2020; 20(1) |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Dental caries experience and socio-economic status among Iranian children: a multilevel analysis
| ||Majid Ghasemianpour,Soheila Bakhshandeh,Armin Shirvani,Naghmeh Emadi,Hamid Samadzadeh,Nadereh Moosavi Fatemi,Anoosheh Ghasemian |
| ||BMC Public Health. 2019; 19(1) |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|