|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 175
How has Internet Addiction been Tracked Over the Last Decade? A Literature Review and 3C Paradigm for Future Research
Xuan-Lam Duong1, Shu-Yi Liaw2, Jean-Luc Pradel Mathurin Augustin3
1 Faculty of Economics and Rural Development, Thai Nguyen University of Agriculture and Forestry, Thai Nguyen Province, Vietnam; Department of Tropical Agriculture and International Cooperation, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology, Pingtung City, Taiwan
2 Management College, Computer Centre, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology, Pingtung City, Taiwan
3 Department of Tropical Agriculture and International Cooperation, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology, Pingtung City, Taiwan
|Date of Submission||27-Apr-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||04-Aug-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||09-Nov-2020|
Management College, Computer Centre, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology, Pingtung City; No. 1, Shuefu Road, Neipu, Pingtung 91201
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: The popularity of the internet aggravated by its excessive and uncontrolled use has resulted in psychological impairment or addiction. Internet addiction is hypothesized as an impulse-control disorder of internet use having detrimental impacts on daily life functions, family relationships, and emotional stability. The goal of this review is to provide an exhaustive overview of the empirical evidence on internet addiction and draw attention to future research themes.
Methods: We performed a literature search on ScienceDirect and PubMed to review original research articles with empirical evidence published on peer-reviewed international journals from 2010 to 2019. Eight hundred and 26 articles were eligible for analysis. Frequency and descriptive statistics were calculated by Microsoft Excel.
Results: A substantial contribution has been coming from researchers from China, Turkey, Korea, Germany, and Taiwan respectively. Despite controversies regarding its definition and diagnostic procedures, internet addiction has become the focal point of a myriad of studies that investigated this particular phenomenon from different exposures. Given observed literature review data regarding research design, data acquisition, and data analysis strategies, we proposed the 3C paradigm which emphasizes the necessity of research incorporating cross-disciplinary investigation conducted on cross-cultural settings with conscientious cross-validation considerations to gain a better comprehension of internet addiction.
Conclusions: The findings of the present literature review will serve both academics and practitioners to develop new solutions for better characterize internet addiction.
Keywords: 3C paradigm, internet addiction, internet use disorder, problematic internet use
|How to cite this article:|
Duong XL, Liaw SY, Mathurin Augustin JLP. How has Internet Addiction been Tracked Over the Last Decade? A Literature Review and 3C Paradigm for Future Research. Int J Prev Med 2020;11:175
|How to cite this URL:|
Duong XL, Liaw SY, Mathurin Augustin JLP. How has Internet Addiction been Tracked Over the Last Decade? A Literature Review and 3C Paradigm for Future Research. Int J Prev Med [serial online] 2020 [cited 2021 Aug 1];11:175. Available from: https://www.ijpvmjournal.net/text.asp?2020/11/1/175/300434
| Introduction|| |
The internet has become an indispensable part of modern society and its use has grown exponentially, causing internet addiction to become a growing concern across all age groups and countries. Uncontrolled use of the internet significantly affects not only individuals' quality of life and social functioning but impacts their physical and psychological health., Despite its ongoing controversy and debate concerning its conceptualization and classification among the scientific community, internet addiction has received increasing attention over the past decades. Researchers initially considered internet addiction as part of the impulse-control disorder and/or obsessive-compulsive disorder models or belonged to behavioural addiction spectrum, because it exhibits the features of excessive use despite adverse consequences, withdrawal phenomena, and tolerance that typify many substance use disorders. Neither a conclusive nor an agreed-upon definition for this disorder has been reached, making it difficult to establish a coherent picture of the phenomenon. Moreover, central discussions around internet addiction are further complicated by serious flaws in research designs as most studies are reliant on self-reported data recruited via multiple channels particularly prone to selection bias. The present study strives to highlight some key elements believed to cover all critical aspects of internet addiction. We also attempted to single out some key elements in the articles such as: research design, data collection, and data analysis strategies. Critical research priorities are provided to establish a concrete set of research preferences for better-managed prospective investigations. It is expected that such initiatives will, at least in part, orientate current and future research agendas to accommodate research trends across a broader spectrum with better knowledge of internet addiction.
The following section dedicates to outlining the prevalence and evolution of internet addiction, providing a brief overview of internet-related activities that can be engaged online. This is followed by characterizing associated risk factors and psychiatric comorbidity of internet addiction. Subsequently, the current literature on existing instruments that have been using to measure internet addiction is discussed. Finally, contemporary intervention and treatment are going to be delineated.
Generally, prevalence estimates are essential to evaluate the demand for consulting, treatment offers and preventive strategies. Yet, epidemiological studies have reported a significant variance in the prevalence rates among adolescents and young people from 6.3 to 37.9% in Asia., In the United States, it ranges from 0.3 to 8.2%, while in Europe, it has been reported to be between 1% and 21.3%., The global pooled prevalence in the general population was estimated to be 6.0%, indicating that internet addiction has been an increasingly alarming issue worldwide. People in Asia, particularly males, have been reported to have a relatively higher likelihood of getting addicted in comparison with their counterparts in non-Asian and female populations., Internet addiction is more prevalent among younger population and this disorder may be more common among lesbian, gay and bisexual individuals than in the heterosexual population. People living in urban areas are more likely to get addicted than their counterparts residing in non-urban regions.,, Nonetheless, caution is needed when drawing conclusions or comparisons among different countries due to the discrepancy in internet access in the populations studied, differences in recruitment of respondents, age-groups included, and dissimilar set of criteria used.
There have been several different proposals about internet addiction classifications. For instance, Young and colleagues perceived internet addiction as an umbrella term for a wide variety of behaviors that divided into five different forms of addictive behavior (i.e., the computer itself, the search for information, cyber sexuality, cyber contracts, and net compulsions including contact with the web through online games, shopping, etc., Davis asserts that pathological internet use consists of two distinct forms: general and specific. While the former refers to a broader set of behaviors, the latter involves engagement with either specific internet functions or applications. Given the ever-increasing ubiquity of internet technology, smartphone use, and web-based application, individuals are susceptible to develop potentially addictive online behaviors. Internet gaming disorder (IGD) was the only internet-related condition officially recognized in the diagnostic manual as a legitimate disorder. IGD is reported to be more frequent in males than in females and tended to be higher among younger rather than older people, yet its prevalence is still inconclusive. The ever-growing prevalence of using social networking sites (SNSs) predominantly among the tech-savvy has raised concerns over its addictive usage. Andreassen and Pallesen defined SNSs addiction as being overly concerned about SNSs due to an uncontrollable urge in which excessive use leads to negative consequences in real-life areas. Yet, little insight into the behavioral characteristics of those who lose control over their SNS use and develop problematic SNS use has led to prevalence rates that varied significantly across studies [Appendix 1]. Cybersex addicts were portrayed as one who uses the internet for sexual purposes for more than 11 hours per week. Afterward, it was defined as any use of internet pornography that creates interpersonal, vocational, or personal difficulties. Although excessive use of the internet for sexual purposes may have positive experiences for individuals, it can either be disordered or addictive. Online shopping addiction refers to a tendency of excessive, compulsive and problematic shopping behavior via the internet that results in consequences associated with economic, social, and emotional problems. The two best distinctions between normal urges to buy and shopping addiction are the negative consequences of the behavior and the fact that items purchased compulsively will not be used as much as expected. Gambling disorder, on the other hand, is fully recognized as a behavioral addiction, characterized by persistent and recurrent maladaptive patterns of gambling behavior, leading to impaired functioning. The online form of gambling consists of wagering and gambling through internet-integrated devices enables bet anonymously and provides continuous instant feedback. These conveniences raise concerns that online gambling could become a contributing factor to the development of gambling disorder and bring about individuals who would otherwise not regularly gamble, to develop a pathological use of internet gambling platforms.
Risk factors for internet addiction
Exploring the patterns of internet addiction and associated factors are necessary to develop preventive measures and treatment protocols. Numerous studies have identified risk factors associated with internet addiction, generally categorized into individual and contextual factors. Specifically, the relationship between personality traits of internet addicts and psychosocial factors has been investigated and reported to have a positive association with neuroticism, extraversion, and openness but a negative relationship with agreeableness and conscientiousness., Poor academic performance and insecure attachment styles were also found to have an association with internet addiction. Rather, family-related factors such as low family functioning,, poor parent-adolescent relationships, low parental monitoring, and parent marital conflict, have been intensively discussed in previous studies. Referring to cultural and economic attributes, internet addiction was found to be positively related to economic well-being, social progress, and human development, whilst negatively related to human well-being, health, safety and security.
Psychiatric comorbidity of internet addiction
The co-occurrence of internet addiction and psychiatric symptoms have been reported in the literature, including, but not limited to personality disorders,, attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD),, hostility, anxiety,, loneliness,, low self-esteem,,, poor self-control, impulsivity,depression,,,alexithymia, and sensation-seeking. Cross-sectional studies on samples of patients reported high comorbidity with psychiatric disorders such as anxiety disorder, problem gambling,, suicidal ideation,, self-injurious and risk-taking behaviour,, eating disorders, and obesity-related problems. Adolescents with internet addiction are more likely to have limited extracurricular activities, and may engage in high-risk behaviours., Other severe consequences of internet addiction have also been reported such as sleep deprivation,, deficient working memory and execution dysfunction. The picture may be more complex, requiring practical responses from supporting agencies such as nursing, psychology, counselling, and social workers.
Measurement of internet addiction
A growing body of research has examined the validity of different measurement scales in different populations, particularly focusing on their psychometric properties and measuring the invariance of these assessment tools to identify internet addicts. Self-reported questionnaires on addictive disorders are often used to assess internet addiction at the general population level. Yet, their reliability and validity have not been adequately determined in terms of having clear diagnostic criteria. To date, multidimensional instruments such as the Internet Addiction Test (IAT), the Chen Internet Addiction Scale (CIAS), and uni-dimensional instruments such as the Compulsive Internet Use Scale (CIUS) have been widely adopted to measure the internet addiction. While the IAT has received overwhelming support for its validity and reliability, yet its accuracy is lower in comparison with CIUS in general population. Differences in the underlying psychometric constructs must be taken into consideration when administering the IAT in different cultural contexts. Consequently, most of the existing scales for internet addiction require further validation.
Intervention and treatment
The response is more effective if the addiction is detected and properly diagnosed as early as possible. However, the evidence-based interventions for internet addiction are sparse, mainly based on strategies previously used in the treatment of substance use disorders. Cognitive-behavioural therapy is currently the most common psychological intervention tested, together with family-based intervention and counselling programs. Further research is required to better clarify formal diagnosis and treatment for internet addiction.
This literature review sought to map contemporary research patterns and provide recommendations for future investigation on internet addiction over the last decade. However, attention was paid only to empirical studies conducted using international or national community or clinical samples. In November 2019, a literature search was performed using two scientific databases: PubMed and ScienceDirect. These two databases had also been used in a prior study for their systematic review of longitudinal research trends in adolescence and emergent adulthood.
The following terms were entered to perform a search through titles and abstracts in the respective databases: “internet AND (addiction* OR ((problematic OR excessive OR pathological AND use)) and “disorder OR compulsive*”. All searches were confined to full-text English papers published between January 2010 and December 2019. The year 2010 was selected as the earliest date for studies, as we firmly believe an emphasis on the last ten years would be the most illustrative and informative to understand existing patterns of internet addiction. Furthermore, given the release of Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) and the inclusion of gaming disorder in the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) as a clinical illness, research trends and patterns discovered within this period are especially important. Publications that were not obtained in the initial search were added after reviewing the reference lists of all retrieved articles.
Once duplicates were removed, the remaining articles were then screened out based on following criteria: (1) contain quantitative, qualitative or mixed approaches; (2) published between January 2010 and December 2019; (3) include general or clinical samples; (4) provide a full-text article and (5) published in English. Articles in languages other than English and those that did not assess internet addiction empirically were not considered. Publications such as theoretical papers, opinion, comments, perspectives, letters to the editor, short communications, conference proceedings, dissertations, and any content derived from sources other than peer-reviewed journals without a clear relationship to internet addiction were also excluded. The extracted data for each publication included: (i) study location, or, in case of not being clearly stated, the country of the first and/or co-author (s), (ii) publication types, (iii) type of study design, (iv) research methods employed and (v) journals that published those manuscripts. Frequency and descriptive statistics were then calculated to derive tables and figures. The whole process for selecting appropriate research articles is presented in [Figure 1] as follows.
| Findings and Discussion|| |
Number of scholarly articles published
Once duplicates and non-relevant articles were eliminated, 826 valid articles remained for further analysis, including 318 indexed in Science Direct and 508 in PubMed [Figure 2].
There was a steady increase in the number of published articles on internet addiction over the last decade. The year with the highest number of publications was 2018 (n = 131), followed by the year 2014 (n = 111). A tentative explanation could be due to research interest stimulated by the inclusion of IGD in Section 3 of the DSM-5. This pattern then recurred in 2018, just one year before gaming disorder is formally recognized as a mental health disorder in the ICD-11. The increase in the number of articles highlights the awareness and importance of this area among the scientific community, clinics, and international bodies worldwide. However, a vast majority of the current literature is primarily centered on adolescents or young students, arguing that they are the most vulnerable groups to potentially develop problematic internet use due to their ever-growing internet use. Yet, their left-behind counterparts (i.e., emerging adults and the elderly), deserve to be assessed thoughtfully as well. Therefore, studies on widening samples across different age groups are necessary to examine whether the association between internet addiction and certain factors is consistent across the general population.
Number of regions (geospatial coverage)
A total of 826 articles were published by authors from 54 different countries [Figure 3]. We took into account the geographical location of the first author or co-author(s) to avoid the misrepresentation that each paper was single-authored.
The most productive countries were China (n = 174, c = 21.06%), Turkey (n = 83, c = 10.05%), Korea (n = 64, c = 7.45%), Taiwan (n = 58, c = 7.02%), Germany (n = 56, c = 6.78%), and the United States (n = 46, c = 5.57%). China has published more than one-fifth of the total articles during the studied timespan, presumably indicating the current situation of internet addiction in this country. In contrast, 36 nations that each published fewer than ten articles (n = 110, c = 13.32%) exhibit a huge disparity in the number of publications compared to the countries in the top five. The previous finding raises a pivotal research agenda for internet addiction experts and practitioners to explore. Therefore, it seems important and beneficial to investigate internet addiction in regions that have not been studied or have been insufficiently studied and then compare the results with previous studies conducted worldwide. Such collaboration is essential to facilitate cross-national and cross-cultural studies employing interdisciplinary approaches to improve the understanding of internet addiction. The European Cooperation in Science and Technology Action Program (COST) under Horizon 2020 can be singled out as a vivid example of its strong commitment to developing fruitful collaborations among researchers, experts, and different stakeholders regarding internet addiction. Likely, the number of publications from this continent would increase considerably in the future.
Common research methods employed
Regarding the research design, the vast majority of studies on internet addiction are cross-sectional (n = 709; c = 85.84%), mostly gathering samples among individuals who may or may not fully represent attributes of the general population. Cross-sectional studies are primarily performed to estimate the prevalence and examine relevant risk factors for internet addiction. This type of study does not have an inherent temporal dimension as it only evaluates subjects at one point in time. By contrast, cohort and case-control studies (n = 51, c = 6.17%) enable researchers to assess the history of the treatment-seekers and endeavour to examine the causal relationship between risk factors and internet addiction. Although cohort and case-control studies have inherent limitations in showing the correlations among different variables and more susceptible to recall and selection bias, they can provide valid results to address important clinical research questions. Yet, interpretation drawn from case-control research should be thoughtfully verified by replication in other designs such as prospective cohort studies. Furthermore, cross-sectional, in comparison with longitudinal studies (n = 66; c = 7.99%) have inherent limitations in determining cause and effect's relationship as they cannot fully ascertain whether a factor was either presented before or after the onset of internet addiction. Therefore, future works would be better suited using alternative methodological approaches to enhance the robustness of the findings and conduct more longitudinal studies to provide valuable insight into the predictors and outcomes.
Concerning data acquisition methods, a substantial amount of research administered surveys (n = 649; c = 78.57%) by applying validated instruments to design self-reported questionnaires either used in the classroom or online environment through crowd-sourcing platforms or some cloud-based survey services to gather the data. Data collected in experimental settings have been used in 92 articles (c = 11.14%), particularly prevalent among brain imaging and neuroimaging studies. Interviews, either face-to-face or in diagnostic form, have been detected in 25 papers (c = 3.02%), showed great promise for the detection of psychiatric comorbidities as they provide greater diagnostic accuracy and contribute to a more exhaustive evaluation. Research that analysed secondary data were reported in 34 studies (c = 4.11%), while the mixed method was employed in 22 studies (c = 2.66%), and only 4 papers (c = 0.48%) applied focus group discussion, a qualitative approach to collecting data.
In terms of analytical techniques, a wide variety of data analysis strategies have been performed to evaluate internet addiction, depending on the type of data collected that allegedly supported researchers dealing with missing data issues and testing the proposed hypotheses or coming into further multivariate analyses [Table 1]. Apart from using traditional approaches to examine the association of possible factors with internet addiction, there is a need for analysis strategies that integrate quantitative and qualitative or mixed approaches and make it possible to identify solve complicate methodological settings. Methods dealing with massive datasets are also required as modern research is increasingly familiar with panel or longitudinal data collecting and processing a large sample of respondents. A prior study provides an approach to examine the severity of internet addiction among college students by using their behaviour data on campus, which can easily be collected through handheld and smart devices.
|Table 1: Top 10 most popular techniques for data analysis on internet addiction|
Click here to view
We observe a growing interest in utilizing structural equation modelling or moderation and mediation analyses to evaluate the mediating role of associated variables. Likewise, latent profile analysis has sufficient flexible capabilities compared to cluster analysis to capture complex contextual effects that are difficult to assess using classical techniques, as it explores patterns of multiple variables rather than the relationship between two variables. Given the drawback of statistical methods, a recent study has employed a machine learning approach with a relatively larger dataset, which subsequently yielded its efficiency and provided a new view for researchers in this area.
A plethora of articles have been published in flagship journals of psychiatry, psychology and human-computer behaviour [Table 2], with only one exception from PLoS One, an interdisciplinary journal that covers primary research from any discipline within science and medicine.
|Table 2: Top 10 journals publishing the most articles on internet addiction|
Click here to view
There would be room for future studies to combine expertise across different fields and use a much more integrative and inclusive approach to investigate internet addiction. Therefore, multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary journals hold great promise for further examination.
Common research topics on internet addiction
In accordance with present research strategies, 826 articles were deliberately classified and then assigned into six categories, namely epidemiological studies - the most commonly investigated topic (n = 384; c = 46.60%), comorbidity studies (n = 283; c = 34.34%), scale measurement studies (n = 80; c = 9.71%), neuroimaging or brain imaging studies (n = 50; c = 6.07%), intervention and treatment studies (n = 23; c = 2.79%), and gene studies (n = 4; c = 0.48%).
The overrepresentation of epidemiological and comorbidity studies reflects the proliferation of internet addiction among psychiatry and psychology disciplines, where so much effort has been dedicated to shedding light on different perspectives on this fairly new topic of interest. Moreover, given that internet addiction is yet to be formally included in any of the official diseases' classifications, it is not surprising that extensive research on its comorbidity and epidemiology dimensions have significantly outweigh other research topics. Likewise, there have been some initial efforts into the heritability of internet addiction by employing a gene approach to evaluate the molecular genetics of this particular behaviour., It is recommended that these topics should be supported with a more detailed analysis in prospective studies.
Additionally, the geographic information system is employed to report maps of internet addiction and then can inform researchers, community organizers, and policymakers on the status quo of internet addiction., An effort has also been paid to apply behavioural economic framework into internet addiction to examine whether the relationship between internet addiction and behavioural economic indicators is similar to other addictive behaviours. These pilot results are expected to support future research that applies behavioral economic models to understand the etiology, developmental course, and to guide prevention and treatment approaches of internet addiction. Furthermore, a scant amount of research has underlined the importance of internet addiction to consumer behavior, particularly paying attention to estimating the association between internet addiction and customers' electronic word-of-mouth behavior in the context of the hotel and restaurant industry., Also, an ecological model called Process-Person-Context-Time has been proposed to examine online activities and internet addiction. Moreover, the application of big data approaches to addiction research for cognition, neuroimaging, and genetics has been introduced. Big data can afford greater replicability of findings, especially in conjunction with the application of artificial intelligence. The advent of machine learning may improve the diagnosis and classification of individual patients based on data patterns that were not consciously considered by clinical in the past. This advanced technology has been used to detect internet addiction by combining grid search and support vector machines to improve detection capabilities.
Future research direction
Although there are major questions remain unanswered regarding the inconclusiveness of internet addiction's definitions as well as the dearth of globally accepted measurements and the variations in prevalence estimates, the association between internet addiction and various cyber-psychosocial-related problems such as cyber-crime, cyber-harassment, cybersecurity, and cyber-bullying is tentative and requires further investigation [Figure 4]. The 15th ed.ition of the World Economic Forum's Global Risks Report contemplates that technological risks can generate a broad-based movement for various collaborators, including scientists and mental health experts, to address. Furthermore, the role of science has evolved to address multifaceted issues, become more interconnected, interdisciplinary, collaborative and data-intensive. As such, collaboration among scholars and experts play a significant role in determining research preferences and allocation of funds and investment for internet addiction research.
Currently, there is neither a single term to unify the concept nor an agreed-upon consensus on diagnostic procedures and definition, making it troublesome to early diagnose and propose sound treatment and intervention arrangements for treatment-seekers. Furthermore, there is a paucity of assessment tools to screen, diagnose and measure internet addiction cross-culturally. Consequently, research is needed to fully describe, from different perspectives, the spectrum of disorders and clinical courses that comprise internet addiction across genders, age groups, and cultures, to attain consensus on the diagnostic thresholds and criteria. Nevertheless, it is ambiguous how internet addiction performs over time. There is an imperative need for longitudinal population-based analysis of incidence, comorbidity, and remission, using extended cohorts (e.g., older adults). Such investigations would accommodate new data about the crucial developments over a lifespan and may introduce novel theories bonding these behaviors and disorders. Furthermore, effective intervention and treatment therapy have not been proved. Early detection of susceptible individuals, aiming at early intervention strategies, could diminish the burden of diseases and help to deter improper functional consequences. To date, cognitive behavioral therapy seems to yield the best results. However, due to study limitations, clear evidence needs to be revealed by further testing.
The 3C paradigm for future research
The aforementioned justifications allow us to formulate the 3C paradigm for future research which accentuates the significance of incorporating a wide range of researchers from multiple disciplines.
- Cross-disciplinary collaborations between scientists from different disciplines have become increasingly important, being a way to learn about cutting-edge knowledge directly from experts and to work towards more integrative and inclusive approaches. Researchers are suggested to cooperate and establish an agreement regarding diagnostic criteria and measures to improve the reliability across studies and to develop effective and efficient treatment approaches for treatment seekers. For research on internet addiction, it is suggested to involve not only academic institutes and research centers but also nursing agencies and public health institutions, particularly where there is a call for projects centered on clinical assessment, intervention, and treatment. While such practices enable the synthesis of ideas and knowledge from many expertise, still, when conducting cross-disciplinary research, institutional or funding-related factors, as well as the conceptual and methodological differences between knowledge domains, must be taken into account
- The cross-cultural study is mainly concerned with looking at how our knowledge about people from one particular culture, and their behavior may or may not be the same as people from another culture. Examining internet addiction at a global scale is valuable in the era of globalization and corporate multi-nationalism. Similarly, studies that assess the commonalities and differences between collectivist and individualist cultures are required as prior studies, have shown that countries in Asia with collectivist cultures are more likely to report higher levels of internet addiction. Finally, researching countries or territories with common cultural determinants such as China, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Macau or conducting research among Spanish or Portuguese communities would also be beneficial and helpful to observe different patterns of internet addiction
- Cross-validation refers to the methods and procedures used to validate results so that they can be generalized. It is useful to check whether a proposed research can generate similar results with the same variables in different samples. Presently, significant efforts have been devoted to examine the reliability and validity of the existing diagnostic instruments and to validate the conceptual model of internet addiction in different populations. Prospective studies should investigate the types of cyberspace activities as previous studies demonstrated that men and women often engage in different types of online activities, i.e., men are more likely to use the internet for playing games, while women mostly use it for social networking and shopping purposes.,, Further in-depth investigations are also required into the validation of clinical instruments, prevalence estimates, and brain-based biology mechanisms to establish a proper conceptualization and more concrete operationalization.
| Conclusion|| |
The goal of this review is to provide an exhaustive overview of the empirical evidence on internet addiction and draw attention on future research topics. We found that the number of journal articles on internet addiction has steadily increased with a substantial contribution from China, Turkey, Korea, Germany, and Taiwan respectively. Internet addiction has predominantly been scrutinized from a psychological, psychiatric and behavioral addiction point of view with considerable amount of research exploring epidemiological, neurobiological, comorbidity, measurement scales to intervention and treatment. Nonetheless, research on internet addiction has been impeded by the use of inconsistent and non-standardized criteria to assess and identify internet addicts or their addictive behavior. Currently, the diagnostic and research landscape appears particularly broad, and diagnostic criteria used to identify internet addiction are not globally agreed upon. Future investigation is prescribed to collaborate cross-disciplines research into cross-cultural studies employing cross-validation methods to allow better generalization of the findings and to gain a deeper insight into the concept of internet addiction.
Several limitations should be addressed in this review. First, the present study considered solely scientific articles confined by a specific interval. Therefore, a more extended timespan could result in meaningful contributions from articles published outside of the range considered in the present study. Second, the search was performed using general and more frequent terms reported in the titles and abstracts of journal articles. Future searches using other specific terms may result in obtaining additional papers on internet addiction. Specific terms relating to internet gaming disorder, shopping addiction, and social networking addiction or any other internet-specific problematic use can also be utilized to generate meaningful information. Finally, the selected databases, although they are the principal bibliography recognized by the global scholarly community, are not the only ones to address these issues. ProQuest, Embase, Medline, Scopus, and PsycINFO are also a great source of literature. Given the present limitations, the findings of this literature review will serve both internet addiction academics and practitioners to develop new solutions based on the challenges identified.[99-109].
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Kuss DJ, Griffiths MD, Karila L, Billieux J. Internet addiction: A systematic review of epidemiological research for the last decade. Curr Pharm Des 2014;20:4026-52.
Li W, Garland EL, Howard MO. Family factors in Internet addiction among Chinese youth: A review of English- and Chinese-language studies. Comput Huma Behav 2014;31:393-11.
Kabasakal Z. Life satisfaction and family functions as-predictors of problematic Internet use in university students. Comput Huma Behav 2015;53:294-304.
Fu KW, Chan WSC, Wong PWC, Yip PSF. Internet addiction: Prevalence, discriminant validity and correlates among adolescents in Hong Kong. Brit J Psychiat 2010;196:486-92.
Young KS. Internet addiction: The emergence of a new clinical disorder. Cyberpsychol Behav 1998;1:237-44.
Davis RA. A cognitive-behavioral model of pathological Internet use. Comput Huma Behav 2001;17:187-95.
Weinstein A, Lejoyeux M. Internet addiction or excessive Internet use. Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse 2010;36:277-83.
Wartberg L, Kriston L, Kammerl R, Petersen KU, Thomasius R. Prevalence of pathological Internet use in representative German sample of adolescents: Results of a Latent Profile Analysis. Psychopathology 2015;48:25-30.
Li YL, Zhang XZ, Lu F, Zhang Q, Wang Y. Internet addiction among elementary and middle school students in China: A nationally representative sample study. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2014;17:111-16.
Aboujaoude E, Koran LM, Gamel N, Large MD, Serpe RT. Potential markers for problematic internet use: A telephone survey of 2,513 adults. CNS Spectr 2006;11:750-5.
Rumpf HJ, Vermulst AA, Bischof A, Kastirke N, Gürtler D, Bischof G, et al
. Occurence of Internet addiction in a general population sample: A latent class analysis. Eur Addict Res 2014;20:159-66.
Carballo JL, Marín-Vila M, Espada JP, Orgilés M, Piqueras JA. Internet abuse risk factors among Spanish adolescents. Span J Psychol 2015;18:e94.
Cheng C, Li AY-L. Internet addiction prevalence and quality of (real) life: A meta-analysis of 31 nations across seven world regions. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2014;17:755-60.
Mak KK, Lai CM, Watanabe H, Kim DI, Bahar N, Ramos M, et al
. Epidemiology of Internet behaviors and addiction among adolescents in six Asian countries. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw. 2014;17:720-28.
Su W, Han X, Jin C, Yan Y, Potenza MN. Are males more likely to be addicted to the internet than females? A meta-analysis involving 34 global jurisdictions. Comput Huma Behav 2019;99:86-100.
Tonioni F, D'Alessandris L, Lai C, Martinelli D, Corvino S, Vasale M, et al
. Internet addiction: Hours spent online, behaviors and psychological symptoms. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2012;34:80-7.
Broman N, Hakansson A. Problematic gaming and Internet use but not gambling may be overrepresented in sexual minorities-A pilot population web survey study. Front Psychol 2018;9:2184.
Cao H, Sun Y, Wan Y, Hao J, Tao FB. Problematic Internet use in Chinese adolescents and its relation to psychosomatic symptoms and life satisfaction. BMC Public Health 2011;11:802.
Stavropoulos V, Alexandraki K, Motti-Stefanidi F. Recognizing internet addiction: Prevalence and relationship to academic achievement in adolescents enrolled in urban and rural Greek high schools. J Adolesc 2013;36:565-76.
Yasuma N, Watanabe K, Nishi D, Ishikawa H, Tachimori H, Takeshima T, et al
. Urbanization and Internet addiction in a nationally representative sample of adult community residents in Japan: A cross-sectional, multilevel study. Psychiatry Res 2019;273:699-05.
Young KS. Internet addiction: Symptoms, evaluation and treatment. Innov Clin Pract 1999;17:19-31.
Mihara S, Higuchi S. Cross-sectional and longitudinal epidemiological studies of Internet gaming disorder: A systematic review of the literature. Psychiat Clin Neuros 2017;71:425-44.
Andreassen CS, Pallesen S. Social network site addiction-An overview. Curr Pharm Des 2014;20:4053-61.
Cooper A, Putnam DE, Planchon LA, Boies SC. Online sexual compulsivity: Getting tangled in the net. Sex Addict Compulsivity 1999;6:79-104.
Twohig MP, Crosby JM, Cox JM. Viewing Internet pornography: For whom is it problematic, how, and why? Sex Addict Compulsivity 2009;16:253-66.
Daneback K, Ross MW, Månsson SA. Characteristics and behaviors of sexual compulsives who use the Internet for sexual purposes. Sex Addict Compulsivity 2006;13:53-67.
Zhao H, Tian W, Xin T. The development and validation of the online shopping addiction scale. Front Psychol 2017;8:735.
American Psychiatric Association (APA). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th
ed. Washington: American Psychiatric Association; 2013.
Gainsbury SM, Russell A, Hing N, Wood R, Lubman D, Blaszczynski A. How the Internet is changing gambling: Findings from an Australian Prevalence Survey. J Gambl Stud 2015;31:1-15.
Gainsbury SM, Wood R. Internet gambling policy in critical comparative perspective: The effectiveness of existing regulatory frameworks. Int Gambl Stud 2011;11:309-23.
Zhou Y, Li D, Li X, Wang Y, Zhao L. Big five personality and adolescent Internet addiction: The mediating role of coping style. Addict Behav 2017,64:42-8.
Shi M, Du TJ. Associations of personality traits with internet addiction in Chinese medical students: The mediating role of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder symptoms. BMC Psychiatry 2019;19:183.
Chen YL, Chen SH, Gau SS-F. AHDH and autistic traits, family function, parenting style, and social adjustment for Internet addiction among children and adolescents in Taiwan: A longitudinal study. Res Dev Disabil 2015;39:20-31.
Odacı H, Çıkrıkçı Ö. Problematic Internet use in terms of gender, attachment styles and subjective well-being in university students. Comput Huma Behav 2014;32:61-6.
Wartberg L, Kammerl R, Rosenkranz M, Hirschhauser L, Hein S, Schwinge C, et al
. The interdependence of family functioning and problematic Internet use in a representative quota sample of adolescents. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2014;17:14-18.
Li J, Li D, Jia J, Li X, Wang Y, Li Y. Family functioning and Internet addiction among adolescent males and females: A moderated mediation analysis. Child Youth Serv Rev 2018;91:289-97.
Boniel-Nissim M, Sasson H. Bullying victimization and poor relationships with parents as risk factors of problematic Internet use in adolescence. Comput Huma Behav 2018;88:176-83.
Yang C, Zhu L, Chen Q, Song P, Wang Z. Parent marital conflict and Internet addiction among Chinese college students: The mediating role of father-child, mother-child, and peer attachment. Comput Huma Behav 2016;59:221-9.
Gao T, Meng X, Qin Z, Zhang H, Gao J, Kong Y, et al
. Association between parental marital conflict and Internet addiction: A moderated mediation analysis. J Affect Disord 2018;240:27-32.
Błachnio A, Przepiórka A, Gorbaniuk O, Benvenuti M, Ciobanu AM, Senol-Dural E, et al
. Cultural correlates of Internet addiction. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2019;22:258-63.
Floros G, Siomos K, Stogiannidou A, Giouzepas I, Garyfallos G. Comorbidity of psychiatric disorders with Internet addiction in a clinical sample: The effect of personality, defense style and psychopathology. Addict Behav 2014;39:1839-45.
Zadra S, Bischof G, Besser B, Bischof A, Meyer C, John U, et al
. The association between Internet addiction and personality disorders in a general population-based sample. J Behav Addict 2016;5:691-99.
Bielefeld M, Drews M, Putzig I, Bottel L, Steinbuchel T, Dieris-Hirche J, et al
. Comorbidity of Internet use disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: Two adult case-control studies. J Behav Addict 2017;6:490-504.
Kawabe K, Horiuchi F, Miyama T, Jogamoto T, Aibara K, Ishii E, et al
. Internet addiction and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder symptoms in adolescents with autism spectrum disorder. Res Dev Disabil 2019; 89:22-8.
Stavropoulos V, Kuss DJ, Griffiths MD, Wilson P, Motti-Stefanidi F. MMORPG gaming and hostility predict Internet addiction symptoms in adolescents: An empirical multilevel longitudinal study. Addict Behav 2017;64:294-300.
Younes F, Halawi G, Jabbour H, El Osta N, Karam L, Hahh A, et al
. Internet addiction and relationship with insomnia, anxiety, depression, stress and self-esteem in university students: A cross-sectional design study. PloS One 2016;11:e0161126.
Stavropoulos V, Gomez R, Steen E, Beard C, Liew L, Griffiths MD. The longitudinal association between anxiety and Internet addiction in adolescence: The moderating effect of classroom extraversion. J Behav Addict 2017;6:237-47.
Demir Y, Kutlu M. The relationship between loneliness and depression: Mediation role of Internet addiction. Ed Process Int J 2016;5:97-105.
Simcharoen S, Pinyopornpanish M, Haoprom P, Kuntawong P, Wongpakaran N, Wongpakaran T. Prevalence, associated factors and impact of loneliness and interpersonal problems on Internet addiction: A study in Chiang Mai medical students. Asian J Psychiatr 2018;31:2-7.
Yao MZ, He J, Ko DM, Pang KC. The influence of personality, parental behaviors, and self-esteem on Internet addiction: A study of Chinese college students. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2014;17:104-10.
Mei S, Yau YHC, Chai J, Guo J, Potenza MN. Problematic Internet use, well-being, self-esteem and self-control: Data from a high-school survey in China. Addict Behav 2016;61:74-9.
Li W, Zhang W, Xiao L, Nie J. The association of Internet addiction symptoms with impulsiveness, loneliness, novelty seeking and behavioral inhibition system among adults with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Psychiatry Res 2016;243:357-64.
Dieris-Hirche J, Bottel L, Bielefeld M, Steinbuchel T, Kehyayan A, Dieris B, et al
. Media use and Internet addiction in adult depression: A case-control study. Comput Huma Behav 2017;68:96-103.
Seki T, Hamazaki K, Natori T, Inadera H. Relationship between Internet addiction and depression among Japanese university students. J Affect Disord 2019; 256:668-72.
Bolat N, Yavuz M, Eliaçık K, Zorlu A. The relationships between problematic Internet use, alexithymia levels and attachment characteristics in a sample of adolescents in a high school, Turkey. Psychol Health Med 2017;23:604-11.
Müller KW, Dreier M, Beutel ME, Wölfling K. Is sensation seeking a correlate of excessive behaviors and behavioral addictions? A detailed examination of patients with gambling disorder and Internet addiction. Psychiatry Res 2016;242:319-25.
Yau YHC, Pilver CE, Steinberg MA, Rugle LJ, Hoff RA, Krishnan-Sarin S, et al
. Relationships between problematic Internet use and problem-gambling severity: Findings from a high-school survey. Addict Behav 2014;39:13-21.
Geisel O, Panneck P, Hellweg R, Wiedemann K, Müller CA. Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis activity in patients with pathological gambling and Internet use disorder. Psychiatry Res 2015;226:97-102.
Kim K, Lee H, Hong JP, Cho MJ, Fava M, Mischoulon D, et al
. Poor sleep quality and suicide attempt among adults with internet addiction: A nationwide community sample of Korea. PLoS One 2017;12:e0174619.
Wang W, Zhou DD, Ai M, Chen XR, Lv Z, Huang Y, et al
. Internet addiction and poor quality of life are significantly associated with suicidal ideation of senior high school students in Chongqing, China. PeerJ 2019;7:e7357.
Kaess M, Durkee T, Brunner R, Carli V, Parzer P, Wasserman C, et al
. Pathological Internet use among European adolescents: Psychopathology and self-destructive behaviors. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2014;23:1093-102.
Oktan V. An investigation of problematic Internet use among adolescents in terms of self-injurious and risk-taking behavior. Electron Commer Res Appl 2015;52:63-7.
Alpaslan AH, Koçak U, Avci K, Uzel TH. The association between Internet addiction and disordered eating attitudes among Turkish high school students. Eat Weight Disord 2015;20:441-8.
Park S, Lee Y. Associations of body weight perception and weight control behaviors with problematic Internet use among Korean adolescents. Psychiatry Res 2017;251:275-80.
Jiang Q, Huang X, Tao R, Examining factors influencing Internet addiction and adolescent risk behaviors among excessive Internet users. Health Commun 2018;33:1434-44.
Gansner M, Belfort E, Cook B, Leahy C, Colon-Perez A, Mirda D, et al
. Problematic Internet use and associated high-risk behavior in an adolescent clinical sample: Results from a survey of psychiatrically hospitalized youth. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2019;22:349-54.
Tan Y, Chen Y, Lu Y, Li L. Exploring associations between problematic Internet use, depressive symptoms and sleep disturbance among Southern Chinese adolescents. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2016;13:313.
Zhou Z, Zhou H, Zhu H. Working memory, executive function and impulsivity in Internet-addictive disorders: A comparison with pathological gambling. Acta Neuropsychiatr 2015;28:92-100.
Moon SJ, Hwang JS, Kim JY, Shin AL, Bae SM, Kim JW. Psychometric properties of the Internet Addiction Test: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2018;21:473-84.
Chen L, Nath R. Understanding the underlying factors of Internet addiction across cultures: A comparison study. Electron Commer Res Appl 2016;17:38-48.
Yong RKF, Inoue A, Kawakami N. The validity and psychometric properties of the Japanese version of the Compulsive Internet Use Scale (CIUS). BMC Psychiatry 2017;17:201.
Kim S, Noh D. The current status of psychological intervention research for Internet addiction and Internet gaming disorder. Issues Ment Health Nurs 2019;40:335-41.
Anderson EL, Steen E, Stavropoulos V. Internet use and problematic Internet use: A systematic review of longitudinal research trends in adolescence and emergent adulthood. Int J Adolesc Youth 2017;22:430-54.
Fineberg NA, Demetrovics Z, Stein DJ, Ioannidis K, Potenza MN, Grünblatt, E, et al
. Manisesto for a European research network into problematic usage of the Internet. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol 2018;28:1232-46.
Peng W, Zhang X, Li X. Intelligent behavior data analysis for Internet addiction. Sci Programming-Neth 2019;2019:1-12.
Stanley L, Kellermanns FW, Zellweger TM. Latent profile analysis: Understanding family firm profiles. Fam Bus Rev 2016;30:84-102.
Di Z, Gong X, Shi J, Ahmed HOA, Nandi AK. Internet addiction disorder detection of Chinese college students using several personality questionnaire data and support vector machine. Addict Behav Rep 2019;10:100200.
Montag C, Kirsch P, Sauer C, Markett S, Reuter M. The role of the CHRNA4 gene in Internet addiction. J Addict Med 2012;6:191-5.
Li M, Chen J, Li N, Li X. A twin study of problematic Internet use: Its heritability and generic association with effortful control. Twin Res Hum Genet 2014;17:279-87.
Lee CS, McKenzie K. Socioeconomic and geographic inequalities of Internet addiction in Korean adolescents. Psychiatry Investig 2015;12:559-62.
Novais MAP, De Liberal MMC, Nappo SA, Zucchi P. Health professionals' perception related to communication technologies for access to information about crack. Int J Prev Med 2020;11:1.
Acuff SF, MacKillop F, Murphy JG. Applying behavioral economic theory to problematic Internet use: An initial investigation. Psychol Addict Behav 2018;32:846-57.
Israeli AA, Lee SS, Karpinski AC. The relationship between Internet addiction and negative eWOM. Serv Ind J 2018;39:943-65.
Israeli AA, Lee SA, Bolden EC. The impact of escalating service failures and internet addiction behavior on young and older customers' negative eWOM. J Hosp Tour Manag 2019;39:150-7.
Li J, Mau W-CJ. Application of an ecological approach to examine online activities and Internet addiction among college students. J Couns Prac 2018;9:1-22.
Whelan R, Cao Z, O'Halloran L, Pennie B. Genetics, imaging, and cognition: Big data approaches to addiction research. In: Verdejo-Garcia, editor. Cognition and Addiction: A Researcher's Guide From Mechanisms Toward Interventions. Elsevier Inc.; 2020. p. 365-77.
Hadlington L. Human factors in cybersecurity; examining the link between Internet addiction, impulsivity, attidutes towards cybersecurity, and risky cybersecurity behaviours. Heliyon 2017;3:e00346.
Chang FC, Chiu CH, Miao NF, Chen PH, Lee CM, Chiang JT, et al
. The relationship between parental mediation and Internet addiction among adolescents, and the association with cyberbullying and depression. Compr Psychiatry 2015;57:21-8.
World Economic Forum. The Global Risks Report 2020. 15th
ed. Geneva: World Economic Forum; 2020.
King DL, Delfabbro PH, Doh YY, Wu AMS, Kuss DJ, Pallesen S, et al
. Policy and prevention approaches for disordered and hazardous gaming and internet use: An international perspective. Prev Sci 2018;19:233-49.
Knapp B, Bardenet R, Bernabeu MO, Bordas R, Bruna M, Calderhead B, et al
. Ten simple rules for a successful cross-disciplinary collaboration. PLoS Comput Biol 2015;11:e1004214.
Kuss DJ, Lopez-Fernandez O. Internet addiction and problematic Internet use: A systematic review of clinical research. World J Psychiatry 2016;6:143-76.
Stodt B, Brand M, Sindermann C, Wegmann E, Li M, Zhou M, et al
. Investigating the effects of personality, Internet literacy, and use expectancies in Internet-use disorder: A comparative study between China and Germany. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018;15:579.
Sariyska R, Reuter M, Bey K, Sha P, Li M, Chen YF, et al
. Self-esteem, personality and Internet addiction: A cross-cutural comparison study. Pers Individ Differ 2014;61-62:28-3.
Durkee T, Kaess M, Carli V, Parzer P, Wasserman C, Floderus B, et al
. Prevalence of pathological Internet use among adolescents in Europe: Demographic and social factors. Addiction 2012;107:2210-22.
Tang CS-K, Koh YW, Gan YQ. Addiction to Internet use, online gaming, and online social networking among young adults in China, Singapore, and the United States. Asia Pac J Public Health 2017;00:1-10.
Rosenkranz T, Müller KW, Dreier M, Beutel ME, Wölfling K. Addictive potential of Internet applications and differential correlates of problematic use in Internet gamers versus generalized Internet users in a representative sample of adolescents. Eur Addict Res 2017;23:148-56.
Müller KW, Janikian M, Dreier M, Wölfling K, Beutel ME, Tzavara C, et al
. Regular gaming behavior and internet gaming disorder in European adolescents: Results from a cross-national representative survey of prevalence, predictors, and psychopathological correlates. Eur Child Adoles Psychiatry 2015;
King DL, Delfabbro PH, Zwaans T, Kaptsis D. Clinical features and axis I comorbidity of Australian adolescent pathological Internet and video-game users. Aust NZ J Psychiat 2013;47:1058-67.
Haug S, Castro RP, Kwon M, Filler A, Kowatsch T, Schaub MP. Smartphone use and smartphone addiction among young people in Switzerland. J Behav Addict 2015;4:299-307.
Davey S, Davey A. Assessment of smartphone addiction in Indian adolescents: A mixed method study by systematicreview and meta-analysis approach. Int J Prev Med 2014;5:1500-11.
Grant JE, Lust K, Chamberlain SR. Problematic smartphone use associated with greater alcohol consumption, mental health issues, poorer academic performance, and impulsivity. J Behav Addict 2019;8:335-42.
Bányai F, Zsila Á, Király O, Maraz A, Elekes Z, Griffiths MD, et al
. Problematic social media use: Results from a large-scale nationally representative adolescent sample. PLoS One 2017;12:e0169839.
Tang CS, Koh YY. Online social networking addiction among college students in Singapore: Comorbidity with behavioral addiction and affective disorder. Asian J Psychiatr 2017;25:175-8.
Ko YM, Roh S, Lee TK. The association of problematic internet shopping with dissociation among South Korean internet users. Int J Env Res Pub He 2020;17:3235.
Müller A, Steins-Loeber S, Trotzke P, Vogel B, Georgiadou E, de Zwaan M. Online shopping in treatment-seeking patients with buying-shopping disorder. Compr Psychiatry 2019;94:152120.
Fuss J, Briken P, Stein DJ, Lochner C. Compulsive sexual behavior disorder in obsessive-compulsive disorder: Prevalence and associated comorbidity. J Behav Addict 2019;8:242-8.
McCormack A, Shorter GW, Griffiths MD. An examination of participation in online gambling activities and the relationship with problem gambling. J Behav Addict 2013;2:31-41.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]
[Table 1], [Table 2]